*Please be mindful of your pickup time BEFORE submitting your order.
Scratch Baking
84 Broad Street, Milford, CT
Pickup Only
Featured Items

Iced Coffee
Organic dark roast.$3.65
Latte - Iced
Espresso with milk, served over ice$4.50
Bacon, Egg and Cheese
*no substitutions or additions* - Daily roll with an egg, aged cheddar cheese, and crispy bacon *roll may be different than photo shown*$7.25
BREAKFAST
Next Day Ordering

Looking to order for tomorrow?
Please wait until after 5pm to place next-day orders! If you order during our operating hours for the next day, items you choose may not be available causing a problem with your order! Thank you!
Savory

Egg and Cheese Sandwich
*no substitutions or additions* - Daily roll with an egg and aged cheddar cheese *roll may be different than photo shown*$6.25
Bacon, Egg and Cheese
*no substitutions or additions* - Daily roll with an egg, aged cheddar cheese, and crispy bacon *roll may be different than photo shown*$7.25
Bacon And Vegetable Quiche
Bacon and spinach$7.35
Vegetarian Quiche
Roasted red peppers and onions$7.35
Everything Bagel
Our classic bagel coated in our housemade everything seasoning$3.70
#1 Breakfast Pizza
Homefries, spinach, egg and cheddar$6.25
#2 Breakfast Pizza
Bacon, home fries, spinach, egg and cheddar$6.25
#3 Breakfast Pizza
Turkey à la King - Scratch-roasted turkey, mushrooms, peas and a creamy, thyme sherry sauce$6.25
#4 Breakfast Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan - breaded eggplant, mozzarella, Parmesan and marinara sauce$6.25
Savory Croissant
Flaky croissant filled with ham, aged cheddar cheese, and Düsseldorf mustard. Available Thursday through Saturday.$5.75
Morning Pastry

Cinnamon Scone
A Scratch classic - a cinnamon scone layered with walnut butter$4.75
Cranberry Orange Scone
An orange flavored scone studded with dried cranberries and finished with sanding sugar for a slight crunch$4.75
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Scone
A pumpkin flavored scone studded with chocolate chips, finished with sanding sugar and more chocolate chips$4.75
Cheddar and Chive Biscuit
Biscuits loaded with cheddar cheese and fresh chives$4.75
Monkey Bread
Croissant dough tossed with cinnamon sugar, baked in a muffin tin, and then topped with a sweet citrus glaze$4.75
Chocolate Croissant
Flaky croissant dough filled with chocolate batons$5.15
Croissant
Croissants are mixed, laminated, shaped, and baked all in house! You can see the love in all those layers!$4.75
Almond Croissant
Flaky croissant filled and topped with almond cream, then coated in slivered almonds$5.75
Chocolate Almond Croissant
Our classic, flaky chocolate croissant filled with out almond cream and finished with slivered almonds and powdered sugar$6.25
Dubai Chocolate Croissant
Our classic croissant filled with a pistachio, tahini and phyllo dough filling, finished with a crisp dark chocolate dip and chopped pistachios$6.50
Cinnamon Bun
Classic cinnamon bun loaded with cinnamon filling and drizzled with a cream cheese glaze$5.25
Zucchini Bread Slice (GF)
A slice of gluten free zucchini bread topped with sesame seeds$5.45
Cider Donut Slice
A thick slice of moist, apple cider loaf, brushed with butter and rolled in cinnamon sugar$4.35
Cinnamon Knot
A sweet twisted pastry made of sweet dough and cinnamon sugar schmere$4.50
Boston Cream Donut
A baked, brioche donut filled with vanilla pastry cream and topped with chocolate ganache$4.00
Caramel Apple Danish
A laminated brioche danish filled with cheese danish filling, cinnamon sugar apples, streusel, and finished with a drizzle of caramel.$6.50Caramel Brownie Croissant
Our classic croissant dough with a salted caramel brownie core and a syrup brushed, laminated chocolate topping$6.50
Pumpkin Pie Poptart
Our classic pastry filled with a pumpkin pie filling, topped with vanilla glaze and Fall sprinkles$5.25
Coffee Cake Slice
A slice of our classic coffee cake topped with cinnamon streusel and powdered sugar$4.35
8” Coffee Cake
An 8” square coffee cake topped with cinnamon streusel and powdered sugar. Serves 9-12.$29.00
Muffins

Blueberry Crumb Muffin
A moist muffin filled with blueberries and topped with streusel$4.35
Mixed Berry Zucchini Muffin
A zucchini based muffin filled and topped with assorted berries - dairy free!$4.35
Apple Cider Muffin
A moist apple cider muffin filled with fresh sliced apples and topped with streusel$4.35
Morning Glory Muffin
A muffin filled with carrots, zucchini, and walnuts - dairy free!$4.35
Corn Muffin with Honey Butter
A sweet corn muffin with a dollop of honey butter offered on the side$4.35
Pumpkin Cheesecake Muffin
A pumpkin spice muffin with a cheesecake center and streusel$4.35
TOAST

Avocado Toast #1
Toasted sourdough topped with mashed avocado, sliced hard boiled egg, pickled red onions, microgreens, salt and pepper$9.75
Avocado Toast #2
Toasted sourdough topped with mashed avocado, sliced tomato, microgreens, pickled radishes, toasted sesame seeds, salt and pepper$9.75
GRAB-AND-GO

Yogurt Parfait
Plain, unsweetened Greek yogurt layered with fresh fruit and topped with our housemade granola$7.85
Granola
House-made granola filled with assorted nuts and dried fruit, lightly sweetened with honey$13.50
Organic Dark Roast - Bonjo Coffee Roasters (1lb)
One pound of organic, dark roast coffee by Bonjo Coffee Roasters (Stamford, CT). Papua New Guinea - Certified Grade A Organic Whole Bean Coffee$22.00
Croissant Chicken Salad Sandwich
No substitutions! Our classic butter croissant with our Waldorf chicken salad (contains walnuts, scallions and dried cranberries lightly dressed) and romaine lettuce.OUT OF STOCK$13.50
Waldorf Chicken Salad Container (8oz)
An 8oz container of our Waldorf Chicken Salad - contains poached chicken, walnuts, dried cranberries, scallions, and apples with a light mayonnaise based dressing.$7.85
Tuna Salad Container (8oz)
An 8oz container of our tuna salad - made with tuna, capers, celery, red peppers, onions, mayo and Cajun seasoning)$7.85
BREAD
Next Day Ordering

Looking to order for tomorrow?
Please wait until after 5pm to place next-day orders! If you order during our operating hours for the next day, items you choose may not be available causing a problem with your order! Thank you!
Bread

Ciabatta Loaf
Rustic Italian loaf - crusty and soft all at once$7.00
Ciabatta Roll
Rustic Italian bread in a smaller roll size$1.95
Honey Flax
Hearty flax bread with a touch of honey and pureed raisins$7.75
Demi Baguette
A smaller version of our classic, crusty French-style baguetteOUT OF STOCK$3.75
Challah
Six-braid loaf perfect for dinner or breakfast$9.25
Toasted Sesame Sourdough
Our classic sourdough bread studded with toasted sesame seeds and crusted with more toasted sesame seeds$9.00
Cherry Chocolate Chunk Sourdough Loaf
Baker's choice flavor of the week! Our classic sourdough studded with dried cherries and chocolate chunks$9.00
Cranberry Pecan Rye
Light rye bread studded with cranberries, pecans, and caraway seeds$9.00
day old Pumpkin Sage Challah
A round challah loaf with a light pumpkin flavor. Studded with pumpkin seeds and topped with flaky sea saltOUT OF STOCK$4.00
Apple Babka
A soft, sweet braided loaf flavored with cinnamon and cooked apples$14.50
Chicken Parm Stuffed Bread
A classic Italian bread stuffed with chicken cutlets, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese$10.00Day Old Rolls
A bag of day old rollsOUT OF STOCK$3.00
DESSERT
Next Day Ordering

Looking to order for tomorrow?
Please wait until after 5pm to place next-day orders! If you order during our operating hours for the next day, items you choose may not be available causing a problem with your order! Thank you!
Bars and More

Raspberry Bar
A sweet crust with a thick layer of raspberry jam topped with streusel$4.25
Pecan Bar
Pecan pie in an individual bar size - full of pecans and gooey caramel$4.75
Colorado Bar
A soft granola bar with oats, dried cranberries, and sunflower seeds - Vegan!$4.25
Cowboy Bar
An oat shortbread topped with chocolate chips, pecans, coconut, and caramel$4.25
Desserts
Moist gluten free loaf loaf cake with almond confectioner glaze

Full Size Flourless Cake
Rich, fudgy chocolate cake - Gluten-free! Serves 12-16.$48.00
Slice of Flourless Cake
Rich, fudgy chocolate cake - Gluten-free!$6.00
Crème Brulee
A classic creme brulee with a toasted sugar top - Gluten-free!$7.85
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Fudgy brownie filled with chocolate chips and finished with melted white, milk and dark chocolate$4.50
Salted Caramel Brownie
Fudgy brownie topped with swirls of chocolate and caramel, finished with flakes of sea salt$4.50
Pumpkin Cheesecake Brownie
Our classic fudge brownie swirled with a pumpkin cheesecake$4.75
Weekend Specials

Full Size Carrot Picnic Cake
An 8" square Carrot Cake topped with swirls of cream cheese frosting and decorated with caramel swirl (serves 9 - 12)$30.00
9" Apple Crumb Pie
9" deep dish apple crumb pie. Made with a classic pie crust, homemade apple pie filling and a cinnamon streusel topping. Serves 8-10.$36.009” Maple Chai Cheesecake Pie
Inspired by Christina’s bake on Food Network’s Holiday Baking Competition! A 9” Chai flavored cheesecake with a spiced speculoos crust and maple whipped cream$36.00
9" Pumpkin Pie
A 9" deep dish pumpkin pie with a classic bottom crust. Serves 8-10.$36.00
9” Pecan Pie
A 9” deep dish pecan pie made with a classic butter crust. Feeds 8-10.$38.00
Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich (GF)
Two peanut butter cookies filled with peanut butter mousse, chocolate ganache and rolled in chopped peanuts. Gluten free!$4.75
Chocolate Chip Shortbread
A classic shortbread bar topped with vanilla sugar$2.45
Eclair
Italian classic - Pate Choux filled with pastry cream and topped with ganache.$5.25
Lemon Bar
A classic lemon bar made with fresh squeezed meyer lemon juice.$4.45
Apple Galette
Hand-held apple pie for those on the go - flaky pastry filled with apples and topped with streusel$6.85Fall Spiced Cake Slice
Layers of chocolate cake, spiced buttercream (cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cardamom) finished with vanilla buttercream and fall sprinkles.$7.50
Pumpkin Roulade Slice
A rolled pumpkin cake filled with cream cheese frostingOUT OF STOCK$6.50
Mini Maple Chai Cheesecake
Inspired by Christina’s bake on Food Network’s Holiday Baking Competition! Chai flavored cheesecake with a spiced speculoos crust and maple whipped creamOUT OF STOCK$4.15Pumpkin Decorated Cookie
A royal icing decorated sugar cookie. Decorated to look like a classic orange pumpkin!$3.95
Black Forest Trifle
Inspired by Christina’s bake on Food Network’s Holiday Baking Competition! A cup full of a decadent chocolate cake, white chocolate mousse, and cherry port compote finished with chocolate shavings.OUT OF STOCK$8.25
Carrot Picnic Cake Slice
A square slice of our classic carrot cake (no nuts or raisins), frosted with cream cheese frosting$4.75
Chocolate Mousse Bomb
Classic pate choux filled with chocolate mousse and topped with torched meringue$5.95
Mini Pumpkin Pie
Our classic butter crust filled with our homemade pumpkin pie filling and finished with whipped cream$7.85
Mini Pecan Pie
An individual sized pecan pie with classic butter crustOUT OF STOCK$8.50Earl Grey Panna Cotta (GF)
Earl grey flavored panna cotta topped with a layer of apricot jam, fresh whipped cream and garnished with earl grey tea$7.85
Chocolate Raspberry Cupcake
A chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache, frosted with a raspberry buttercream and finished with chocolate sprinkles.$4.15
Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.95
Confetti Sugar Cookie
$1.95
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$1.95
Espresso Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.95
Brown Butter Pecan Cookie
An oversized delicious brown butter cookie studded with pecans and chocolate chips$3.65
DRINKS
Next Day Ordering

Looking to order for tomorrow?
Please wait until after 5pm to place next-day orders! If you order during our operating hours for the next day, items you choose may not be available causing a problem with your order! Thank you!
Coffee and Tea

Hot Coffee
Organic dark roast.$3.00
Hot Tea
SerendipiTea loose leaf tea$3.00
Iced Coffee
Organic dark roast.$3.65
Iced Tea
SerendipiTea iced tea. Brewed in house.$3.95
Iced Tres Leches Coffee
Our signature, iced, dark roast coffee accompanied by our homemade tres leches blend and finished with cinnamon powder. *no dairy free option available*$3.85
Hot Tres Leches Coffee
Our signature dark roast coffee accompanied by our homemade tres leches blend and finished with cinnamon powder. *no dairy free option available*$3.85
Specialty Drinks

Americano - Iced
Espresso over water, served over ice$3.15
Americano - Hot
Espresso poured over hot water$3.15
Café au Lait
Made with equal amounts of our dark roast drip coffee and steamed milk$3.95
Cappuccino
Espresso with steamed milk and foam$4.25
Iced Chai Latte
Iced chai tea with cinnamon syrup and milk$4.85
Chai Steamer - Hot
Chai tea steeped with cinnamon syrup and topped with steamed milk$4.85
Chaider - Hot
Hot apple cider steeped with chai tea and sweetened with caramel$4.25
Chaider - Iced
Apple cider steeped with chai tea and sweetened with caramel - served iced$4.25
Espresso (double shot)
Double shot of organic espresso$2.75
Dirty Chai - Iced
Iced chai tea with espresso, cinnamon syrup and milk$5.95
Dirty Chai - Hot
Chai tea steeped with cinnamon syrup, espresso and topped with steamed milk$5.95
Hot Chocolate
Our decadent homemade hot chocolate$4.85
Latte - Iced
Espresso with milk, served over ice$4.50
Latte - Hot
Espresso with steamed milk$4.50
Lemonade
Made in-house with fresh lemon juice! Served over ice.$4.20
London Fog - Iced
Iced earl grey tea sweetened with our homemade vanilla syrup and finished with milk$4.85
London Fog - Hot
Earl Grey tea steeped with vanilla syrup and topped with steamed milk$4.85
Matcha Lemonade
Our homemade lemonade topped with SerendipiTea matcha - served over ice$5.65
Matcha - Iced
Matcha tea, vanilla syrup and milk served over ice$5.35
Matcha - Hot
Matcha with steamed milk and sweetened with our vanilla syrup$5.35
Mocha - Iced
Espresso, ganache, our homemade hot chocolate mix and milk served over ice$4.85
Mocha - Hot
Espresso and ganache with steamed hot chocolate and milk$4.85
Cans and Bottles

Bottle of Water
Poland Spring water bottle$2.50
Seltzer
assorted La Croix flavors$2.50
MERCH
Next Day Ordering

Looking to order for tomorrow?
Please wait until after 5pm to place next-day orders! If you order during our operating hours for the next day, items you choose may not be available causing a problem with your order! Thank you!
Merchandise

Dog Biscuit
Don't forget the puppies with this almond butter and whole wheat flour based biscuit!$1.50
Organic Dark Roast - Bonjo Coffee Roasters (1lb)
One pound of organic, dark roast coffee by Bonjo Coffee Roasters (Stamford, CT). Papua New Guinea - Certified Grade A Organic Whole Bean Coffee$22.00Baseball Hat (Blue)
Adjustable, Port Authority baseball hat with front and back embroidery$22.00Baseball Hat (Grey)
Adjustable, Port Authority baseball hat with front and back embroidery$22.00
Metal Straw
$2.50Scratch Baking Ornament
A red, glass ornament with our classic, Scratch Baking logo. The perfect gift!$15.00

day old Pumpkin Sage Challah
$4.00
A round challah loaf with a light pumpkin flavor. Studded with pumpkin seeds and topped with flaky sea salt
Request advisory
Additions or special substitutions may result in an upcharge on your bill. If you have any allergies or questions, give us a call at (203-301-4396).
1